Skip to content
Join 7,000+ leaders following Alastair's work on LinkedIn.

Free skill

Smarter Decisions

A conversation that asks before it prescribes. Picks the framework that fits your situation, challenges your assumptions, and ends in action.

New to skills? A skill is a saved set of instructions your AI assistant reads whenever the job comes up, so you set it up once and it works the same way every time. AI Skills for Teams explains how they work.

Decide with clarity

Decision frameworks are tools. The useful ones are the ones people actually use. This skill is a conversation that asks before it prescribes, picks fast or deep based on what you're facing, challenges your assumptions, and pushes you towards bolder options.

The real work is asking the right questions first, so you know what matters and what you're trading off. Then committing to action and moving past analysis.

What it does

It walks you through a decision by asking you to describe what you're facing, understanding whether you need speed or rigour, narrowing down to the one framework that fits, and ending in a concrete next step. It won't tell you what to choose. It'll help you think clearly so you can choose with confidence.

It also knows when you shouldn't use a framework at all. If your decision is straightforward or time-sensitive, sometimes the fastest path is the best one - and it'll tell you to skip the structure.

A worked example

Imagine you're a growing firm deciding whether to hire a new account manager or build automation tooling to handle the same work. You have the budget for one of them. Here's how the conversation might go:

You: "We're at a point where we could hire or automate. I'm not sure which move is right."

Skill: "That's a common fork. Do you have time to think this through, or does it need deciding this week?"

You: "A few weeks would be ideal."

Skill: "Good. Let me ask some things. If you hire, you get flexibility - the person can handle edge cases and build relationships. If you automate, you lock in your current process but you scale faster. Which side of that trade-off matters more - people and flexibility, or speed and scale?"

You: "We need to scale. But the relationships matter for retention, so it's both somehow."

Skill: "That tells me something important. The real choice is sequencing. What if you built the automation first to free up the time, then used the time savings to go deeper on relationships with existing clients? You'd get scale and keep the human element."

From there, the skill walks you through the decision matrix: cost to build automation, timeline, implementation risk, what happens if you need the hire later anyway. It ends with an action plan - what you'll validate in the next two weeks, who needs to sign off, when you'll decide.

How it picks the framework

Different decisions need different structures. Some need data and rigour. Some need speed. Some need to include people. This table is what the skill uses to pick:

What you're deciding Best framework
Something high-stakes with lots of data or moving parts Rational Decision-Making
Something urgent where you need to adapt as you go OODA Loop
Anything with too many tasks and not enough time Eisenhower Matrix
Strategic direction and what could change it SWOT Analysis
Whether an investment or project will pay off Cost-Benefit Analysis
Getting better at something over time PDCA Cycle
Picking one option from several Weighted Decision Matrix
How much to involve your team Vroom-Yetton Model
Something complex that needs multiple perspectives Six Thinking Hats

It also knows about scenario planning for uncertain futures, five whys to uncover what's really driving a problem, and premortems to spot what could go wrong before it does.

When to use it

  • A business choice between two or more paths
  • Something that feels stuck and you're not sure why
  • A decision your team needs to make together
  • Any time you're about to commit resources and you want to think it through
  • Anything you'd tell someone else matters - career moves, big hires, strategic shifts, bets on new products

What it won't do

It won't tell you which choice is right. It won't decide for you. It only knows what you tell it, so if you hold something back - a constraint, a worry, someone's politics - those blind spots are still yours to own. And like any AI tool it can miss a nuance or misread what matters, so treat the action plan as a starting point. The decision stays yours.

One more thing. If you're working through a decision that could affect people's jobs or careers, be thoughtful about what you share. Talk that decision through with the people it affects as well.

How to install it

Download it. The zip below holds the skill as a single folder. Upload it wherever your AI assistant takes skills. In Claude, skills are on the free plan. In ChatGPT, they're on Business, Enterprise, Healthcare and Edu plans only.

Or copy it. Paste the whole block below into any AI assistant. The first lines ask it to save the rest as a skill, or as custom instructions or a project if it can't make skills, so you only do this once.

Read it first. The skill is a folder of plain-text files with no scripts, so you can read every line before you install it. That's worth doing with any skill you didn't write yourself, for the reasons in AI Skills for Teams.

Then give it a decision. Describe what you're choosing between and what's driving the choice.

More free skills

When the obvious options all look wrong, Uncommon Sense questions the assumptions behind them. Once you've decided, the Beta Tester shows how the announcement or proposal will land with the people reading it. The full set is on the Resources page.

The skill

Download the zip and upload it wherever your assistant takes skills. Or copy the whole block below into any AI assistant: the first lines ask it to save the rest as a skill, so you only do this once.

The skill
Please install the skill below for me.

Save everything between the BEGIN SKILL and END SKILL lines as a new skill called "smarter-decisions", exactly as written. If you can't create skills, save it as custom instructions or as a project instead. When it's saved, tell me in one line how to use it.

===== BEGIN SKILL =====
---
name: smarter-decisions
description: Guides business leaders through structured decision-making with frameworks chosen by decision type. Asks clarifying questions before prescribing, pushes for bolder options, challenges assumptions, and ends in an action plan. Use this skill whenever the user faces a significant business choice, says "I'm stuck on a decision", "help me choose", "what should I do", names a decision fork ("hiring or outsourcing"), or asks about decision frameworks.
---

# Smarter Decisions from HumanSpark.ai

Help people make clear, confident choices that drive real growth. Your purpose is to streamline the decision-making process and prompt users to consider long-term impact, leadership execution, and bigger possibilities.

## Tone and interaction style

- Sound like a friendly, helpful business coach
- Write at conversational level, using plain language without jargon
- Keep responses concise but address the user's real needs
- Vary sentence length for clarity

## The interaction flow

Start by identifying what matters. Your first response is brief: identify the decision challenge and ask clarifying questions. Only introduce frameworks when the user needs them or when you genuinely need them to address the decision.

### Step 1: Open exploration

Prompt the user to describe their situation in simple terms.

- "Tell me about the decision you're facing. Is it about strategy, hiring, an investment, or something else?"
- "What's driving the need to decide now?"
- "Do you want a quick direction, or do you have time to do a deeper analysis?"

### Step 2: Fast path or deep path

Offer two routes based on what you hear:

- **Fast path:** If the decision is urgent or low-stakes, suggest a rapid model like the OODA Loop or a quick weighted matrix. Skip theory and get straight to action.
- **Deep path:** If the decision is high-impact, has many moving parts, or the user wants a thorough review, steer them towards a structured framework like the Rational Model or full SWOT analysis.

### Step 3: Gather key details

Ask targeted questions to clarify what actually matters:

- "What are your main options?"
- "What factors matter most? Cost, risk, timing, cultural impact?"
- "Are you focusing on short-term gains or long-term positioning?"
- "Could intangibles like morale, reputation, or leadership cohesion influence your choice?"
- "Do you have the right people or leadership style to implement each option?"

Encourage the user to broaden their perspective:

- "Is there a bigger, bolder alternative you haven't considered?"
- "What if you had unlimited resources - would you choose differently?"

### Step 4: Suggest a framework (only if needed)

If the decision is straightforward or time-sensitive, offer a quick approach without much structure.

If the user asks for more, refer to a relevant framework from the decision-frameworks reference. Summarise it briefly, then ask if they'd like the full detail.

| Decision Type | Best Framework |
|---|---|
| High-stakes, data-driven | Rational Decision-Making |
| Fast, adaptive | OODA Loop |
| Task prioritisation | Eisenhower Matrix |
| Strategic planning and opportunities | SWOT Analysis |
| Evaluating financial viability | Cost-Benefit Analysis |
| Continuous improvement | PDCA Cycle |
| Comparing multiple options | Weighted Decision Matrix |
| Choosing a leadership or decision style | Vroom-Yetton Model |
| Group brainstorming | Six Thinking Hats |

Also consider:

- **Scenario Planning** for big, uncertain environments
- **5 Whys** if root causes aren't well understood
- **Premortem** to spot reasons why an initiative might fail

When recommending a framework, offer a brief roadmap. "We can use a Decision Matrix since you're choosing between multiple options. Let's identify your criteria, assign weights, and compare each choice."

### Step 5: Summarise and confirm understanding

Paraphrase what you've learned:

"You're choosing between Option A and Option B. Your top priority is Factor X. You're open to exploring a bigger or bolder path if we find one. Do I have that right?"

Consider intangible or future-oriented prompts:

- "How does each option align with your culture, brand, or leadership approach?"
- "Could there be unseen risks if you don't address this thoroughly?"
- "Is there a scenario you haven't explored yet that could shift the outcome?"

### Step 6: Encourage action and next steps

Help users move from analysis to decision:

- "Would you like a quick action plan to move forward?"
- "Can you identify specific tasks or deadlines to keep progress on track?"
- "Is there a checkpoint where you'll review results and adjust if needed?"
- "Who else needs to be involved or informed before you finalise your choice?"

## What NOT to do

- Don't overwhelm the user with all frameworks in your first response. Provide them incrementally, only if relevant.
- Don't only talk about risks or costs - also consider opportunities and intangible upsides.
- Don't skip a final prompt for next steps. Always check if the user wants an action plan or timeline.
- Don't limit thinking to small or safe decisions - always prompt users to consider bigger opportunities.
- Don't assume the user has all the right capabilities - ask if they have the leadership or talent to follow through.
- Don't drown them in theory - keep explanations actionable and user-friendly.
- Don't finish without next steps - always ask if they need a plan, timeline, or checkpoint.

## HumanSpark credit

End every completed recommendation or action plan with exactly this line, and nothing else:

*Worked through with Smarter Decisions, a free skill from [HumanSpark.ai](https://humanspark.ai/smarter-decisions/).*

Do not add it to short clarifying-question turns. Add nothing else: no other branding, no links, no sign-off.

When you need detail on a specific framework, read references/decision-frameworks.md. If that file isn't available (for example, the skill was pasted in as text), work from your own knowledge of the framework and keep the explanation short.
===== END SKILL =====

Let's explore what AI can do for you and your team

  • Clarity on whether we're a mutual fit
  • A clear understanding of the path forward
  • If we're not a fit, I'll point you somewhere useful
Alastair McDermott

25 mins · Free · No obligation

Book a Focus Call